While not the quintessential World War II epic one might anticipate, “Hanover Street” carves its own niche as a highly watchable film, leaning more into the realms of romance than straight-out war drama or suspense thriller. Revisiting this movie after some time, the intricate plot details may have faded, but the enduring enjoyment stems from two core elements: the stellar cast and the evocative backdrop of World War II London, complete with all the period drama, hairstyles, fashion, and classic automobiles.
The film’s true strength lies in exploring the compelling dynamics between a refined and steadfast husband and a passionate, charismatic lover. This central conflict culminates in a truly memorable ending that lingers long after the credits roll. “Hanover Street” tells the story of Margaret Sellinger, a British nurse stationed in wartime London, and David Halloran, a charming American pilot. Their paths collide during a tense air raid, sparking an undeniable connection that quickly blossoms into love. Unbeknownst to David, Margaret is already married. The complexities deepen when David is tasked with transporting a British secret agent into occupied France, only to discover that this agent is none other than Paul Sellinger, Margaret’s husband. While the situation hinges on a significant coincidence, it undeniably sets the stage for a captivating narrative.
The magnetic pull of “Hanover Street” is further amplified by its exceptional lead actors, each a favorite in their own right. Harrison Ford, with his undeniable charisma and dash, embodies the role of the passionate lover, David. In contrast, the epitome of a gentleman, Christopher Plummer, portrays Paul Sellinger, the older, dependable, and unwavering husband. Leslie-Anne Down, renowned from “Upstairs, Downstairs,” beautifully captures Margaret, the woman torn between these two remarkably compelling men. Faced with a hypothetical choice between Harrison Ford and Christopher Plummer, it’s a genuinely challenging decision – though, for many, Christopher Plummer’s quiet charm might be captivating enough from the outset!
The film subtly touches upon pre-existing marital tensions, hinting at the husband, Paul’s, insecurity about not being exciting enough for Margaret. However, “Hanover Street” largely refrains from explicitly justifying Margaret’s choices, leaving the audience to grapple with their own sympathies. While the wartime setting provides context, the film doesn’t fully explore the motivations behind Margaret’s actions. Despite Harrison Ford’s undeniable appeal, it’s difficult to fully sympathize with Margaret’s boredom. The development of Margaret and David’s relationship feels somewhat rushed. A shared experience of danger during a V2 rocket bombing quickly escalates into an affair. This accelerated progression perhaps contributes to a slight detachment from their romance. While Leslie-Anne Down is captivating in her role, the film offers limited insight into the emotional depth of their connection. Furthermore, Margaret’s initial omission of her marital status to David casts a shadow over her character, arguably generating more compassion for the initially misled lover.
Later in “Hanover Street,” fate throws the husband and lover together in a perilous mission behind enemy lines. Forced to rely on each other for survival amidst enemy threats, their interactions become unexpectedly poignant and compelling. These scenes, showcasing the contrasting yet complementary strengths of the macho, younger Ford and the seasoned, older Plummer, are arguably more captivating than the somewhat underdeveloped romantic relationship between the lovers. Without revealing spoilers about which man, if either, “prevails” in the end, the film’s conclusion leaves a lasting impression.
With such a talented cast and a rich historical backdrop, “Hanover Street” possesses the potential to be a truly exceptional film. However, it could have benefited from a deeper exploration of Margaret’s vulnerability and motivations, a more nuanced development of the central romantic relationship to establish genuine chemistry, and a clearer understanding of the factors leading her to seek solace outside her marriage. Nevertheless, for those with an affinity for wartime romances, “Hanover Street”, particularly with its stellar cast, offers an engaging and ultimately memorable cinematic experience.
