Discover the Delightful Menu at 5th Street Bagelry

A mouth-watering bagel sandwich showcasing fresh ingredients, perfect for a hearty breakfast or lunch option from 5th Street Bagelry.

At 5th Street Bagelry, we believe in crafting food that’s not only delicious but also made with care, right in front of your eyes. Our menu is a testament to this philosophy, offering a wide array of options perfect for starting your day right or enjoying a satisfying lunch. From our locally renowned sandwiches to our hand-crafted coffees and cappuccinos, and of course, our fresh, warm bagels baked daily on-site, we have something to satisfy every craving.

“The food at the bagel shop is great. My husband and kids come in weekly and are treated like family. We grab breakfast for everyone and eat in the atrium so our kids can feed the fish. It’s such a nice place to start the day! I would recommend this local gem to anyone.” – Jennifer P.

Quench Your Thirst with Our Diverse Drink Selection

A variety of coffee pots, highlighting the fresh brewed coffee options available at 5th Street Bagelry.

Start your day or refuel anytime with our extensive drinks menu. Whether you’re a coffee aficionado or prefer something cooler, we’ve got you covered.

Coffee & Espresso

Fresh Brewed Coffee: (Small 12 oz / Large 16 oz)
- Varieties: Columbian, Columbian Decaf, Crazy Caramel, Hazelnut, Highlander Grogg, Cinnamon Twist
- Price: Small $2.75 / Large $3.25
Cappuccino, Latte (Hot or Iced):
- Price: Small $4.50 / Large $5.75
Frozen Cappuccino: (Large 5.75)
- Flavors: Almond, Caramel, Coconut, Hazelnut, Mocha, Vanilla, White Chocolate, Sugar-Free Caramel, Sugar-Free Hazelnut, Sugar-Free Vanilla, Sugar-Free Raspberry
Americano:
- Price: Single $2.35 / Double $3.95
Espresso:
- Price: Single $2.50 / Double $3.95
Iced Coffee: (Large 4.25)

More Refreshing Choices

Hot Tea: (Small 2.25 / Large 2.75)
Hot Cocoa: $3.75
Chai Tea: $4.25
Flavored Steamer: (16oz. 3.75)
Smoothies: (20oz. 4.95 – 150% Vitamin C & Antioxidants)
- Flavors: Mango, Orange Dream, Green Tea, Strawberry, Pina Colada
Soft Drinks:
- Varieties: Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Pibb Extra, Mello Yello, Iced Tea, Lemonade
- Price: 16oz. $2.50 / 20oz. $3.25

Coffee To Go & Party Options

Coffee by the Pound:
- Half Pound Bag: $11.95
- One Pound Bag: $16.95
- Varieties: Columbian, Columbian Decaf, Crazy Caramel, Hazelnut, Highlander Grogg, Cinnamon Twist
Bagel Party Trays For Special Events:
- Small Tray: (12 bagels, 2 @ 1/4 lb cream cheese, butter & jellies) $27.95
- Large Tray: (16 bagels, 3 @ 1/4 lb cream cheese, butter & jellies) $35.95
Pot of Coffee to Go: (96 oz Box – Serves 8 x 12 oz) $25.95 – Customize your favorite blend!

Start Your Day Right with Our Breakfast Selections

Fuel up for the day with our delicious breakfast options, made to order just the way you like them.

Omelette-Your-Way: (With choice of 1 meat & 1 cheese. Veggie choices: Spinach, Bell Peppers, Tomatoes, Onions)
- 2 Eggs: $6.95
- 3 Eggs: $7.95
Biscuits & Gravy Platter: (1 Biscuit & Gravy, Home Fries, 1 Egg & Choice of: 1 Slice of Ham, 2 Slices of Bacon, or 1 Sausage Patty) $8.95
5th St. Breakfast Platter: (2 Eggs anyway, Home Fries, & One Slice Toasted Italian, Wheat or Rye Bread & Choice of: 2 Slices of Ham, 2 Slices of Bacon, or 1 Sausage Patty) $8.95
Scrambled or Fried Egg:
- 1 Egg: $2.75
- 2 Eggs: $4.50
Sides:
- Bacon: (2 Slices $1.95 / 4 Slices $3.95)
- Sausage Patty: (1 Patty $1.95 / 2 Patties $3.50)
- Biscuit & Gravy: (1 Biscuit $2.95 / 2 Biscuits $5.25)
- Home Fries: $2.25
Breakfast Sandwiches:
- Fried Egg & Cheese Sandwich: $5.25
- Fried Egg, One Meat & Cheese Sandwich: $6.50
- Fried Egg, One Meat & Cheese Sandwich With Choice of 2 Meats: (Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Turkey) $7.95

Satisfying Sandwiches for Lunch and Beyond

Close-up of a mocha, showcasing the specialty coffee drinks available at 5th Street Bagelry.

Our sandwiches are crafted with fresh ingredients and your choice of bread, making for a perfect lunchtime treat or a fulfilling meal any time of day.

Bagel Sandwiches:
- Bagel toasted with Butter: $2.25
- Bagel & Cream Cheese: $2.95
- Bagel & Cream Cheese add 2 veggies: $3.95
- Bagel – Peanut Butter & Jelly: $2.95
- Pizza Bagel with Pepperoni: $4.25
- Bagel & Lox: (Cream Cheese, Onions, Tomato, and Capers) $8.95
Specialty Sandwiches:
- Vegetarian Tomato Bravo: (Pesto & Provolone) $5.95
- Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato (BLT): $5.25
- Chicken Salad Sandwich: (Lettuce & Tomato) $6.95
- Tuna Salad Sandwich: (Lettuce & Tomato) $6.95
- Turkey & Cheese Sandwich: (Lettuce & Tomato) $6.95
- Turkey Bacon Ranch Panini: $7.50
- Ham & Cheese Sandwich: (Lettuce & Tomato) $6.95
- Club: (Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato) $7.50
- Reuben: (Turkey or Ham, Saurkraut, 1000 Island on Swirled Rye Bread) $7.50
- Vegetarian Sandwich: (Veggies & 1 Cheese or Hummus) $5.95
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich: $5.25
Salad Plates:
- Chicken Salad or Tuna Salad Plate: (One Scoop of Chicken Salad with Mixed Greens and Veggies, Served with Crackers) $8.95
Sandwich Bread Choices: Bagel, Italian, Swirl Rye, Whole Wheat, Croissant
Cheese Choices: American, Cheddar, Swiss, Pepper Jack, Provolone
Veggie Choices: Banana Peppers, Bell Peppers, Cucumber, Green Leaf Lettuce, Red Onion, Spinach, Tomatoes, Arugula

Soups, Salads, and Extra Deliciousness

Round out your meal with our comforting soups, fresh salads, and tasty extras.

Soup of the Day: (Served with Bagel Chips or Crackers) 12oz. $4.95
Salads:
- Garden Salad: $5.95
- Chef’s Salad: (Garden Veggies, Ham, Bacon, Turkey, and 1 Cheese) $8.95
Extras:
- Bag of Chips: $1.75
- Bag of Bagel Chips: $2.50
- 8oz Bag of Bagel Chips (pre-order please): $9.95
- Potato Salad: $1.65

Freshly Baked Bagels: The Heart of 5th Street Bagelry

A storefront sign for 5th Street Bagelry, inviting customers to enjoy fresh bagels and coffee.

Our bagels are baked fresh daily, ensuring the perfect chewy inside and crisp outside. Choose from a wide variety of flavors to enjoy on their own or as the foundation for your favorite sandwich.

Bagel Varieties

Single Bagel: $1.65
Dozen Bagels: $15.50
Varieties: Apple-Cinnamon, Asiago, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Cinnamon Raisin, Everything, Jalapeño, Maple, Onion, Plain, Pumpernickel, Poppy Seed, Sesame Seed, Sun-Dried Tomato, Wheat, Whole Grain

Cream Cheese & Spreads

Side of Cream Cheese: $1.65
1/4 lb. Cream Cheese: $2.95
1/2 lb. Cream Cheese: $5.95
1 lb. Cream Cheese: $9.95
Cream Cheese Flavors: Apple-Cinnamon, Bacon & Chive, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Garlic Herb, Plain, Strawberry, Veggie, Jalapeno Cheddar
Chicken & Tuna Salad:
- 1/4 lb.: $2.95
- 1/2 lb.: $5.25
- 1 lb.: $8.95

Indulge in Our Baked Sweets

A selection of freshly baked bagels, showcasing the variety and quality at 5th Street Bagelry.

Treat yourself to our freshly baked sweets, perfect for an afternoon pick-me-up or a delightful dessert.

Sweet Treats

Cookie: $1.50
Cinnamon Bun: $2.95
Nutty Sticky Bun: $3.75
Turnover: (Apple or Cherry) $2.95
Brownie: $2.50
Biscotti: $0.95

Muffins & Scones

Muffins: $2.75
- Flavors: Banana Nut, Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, Lemon Poppy Seed, Pistachio
Scones: $2.50
- Flavors: Apple-Cinnamon, Blueberry, Orange-Cranberry, Raspberry White Chocolate

Loaf Breads

Focaccia: (Place your order in advance) $7.95
Italian or Wheat Loaf: $3.95
Croissant: $2.25 each

Click Here For Our Printable Menu

Planning a Party? Let 5th Street Bagelry Cater!

We offer a variety of bagels and baked goods perfect for special orders for your event or party. Contact us for more information, or to inquire about reserving our conference room for your next business meeting!