Welcome to Elm Street Market, your go-to destination for gourmet sandwiches crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Our menu features a diverse selection of deli creations, perfect for a satisfying lunch or a delicious meal any time of day. Explore our signature sandwiches below and discover your new favorite today!
Elm Street Market’s Signature Sandwiches: A Culinary Journey
At Elm Street Market, we pride ourselves on creating unique and flavorful sandwiches that go beyond the ordinary. Each sandwich is carefully constructed with premium ingredients and thoughtful combinations to deliver an exceptional taste experience.
The Deluxe Italian
For lovers of classic Italian flavors, The Deluxe Italian is a must-try. This hearty sub roll is packed with a delicious medley of rosemary sundried tomato ham, salami, and cappy ham. We layer these savory meats with baby spinach, crisp red onions, and picante provolone cheese for a zesty kick. Finally, we drizzle it with our signature Italian deli dressing to complete this flavorful masterpiece.
- Price: $12.00
The Mapleicious
Experience a delightful sweet and savory combination with The Mapleicious. This sandwich features honey maple glazed turkey and ham, perfectly complemented by the sharpness of Vermont cheddar cheese. Crisp Granny Smith apple slices and baby spinach add freshness and texture, while our house-made maple sriracha mayo provides a unique and delicious finishing touch. Served on a soft round roll, it’s a truly unforgettable flavor experience.
- Price: $13.00
The Mayor Mark
The Mayor Mark is a classic American-style sandwich elevated with premium ingredients. We start with OvenGold roasted turkey and layer it with delicate Lacey Swiss cheese and crispy bacon. Shredded iceberg lettuce and ripe tomatoes provide a refreshing crunch, while smashed avocado adds creamy richness. Mayonnaise brings it all together on perfectly toasted white bread for a satisfying and familiar yet refined sandwich.
- Price: $13.00
The Wild Bill
Spice enthusiasts will love The Wild Bill! This sub roll is loaded with blazing buffalo chicken, offering a fiery kick. We balance the heat with shredded iceberg lettuce and crispy French fried onions for texture and coolness. Blue cheese dressing and our house-made jalapeno sauce enhance the buffalo flavor and add extra layers of zesty goodness.
- Price: $13.00
The Monumental
For a truly substantial meal, choose The Monumental. This BIG sub is perfect for a large appetite or to share. It’s piled high with London broil and deluxe ham, complemented by shredded iceberg lettuce, juicy tomatoes, crisp green bell peppers, and red onions. Dill pickle chips add a tangy crunch, and Italian deli dressing ties all the ingredients together in a flavorful and satisfying way.
- Price: $13.00
The Ethan Allen
Looking for a lighter yet flavorful option? The Ethan Allen is our signature curried chicken breast salad wrap. Our own curried chicken salad is combined with creamy chevre goat cheese and fresh baby spinach. Mayonnaise adds moisture and richness, all wrapped in a soft and convenient wrap.
- Price: $12.00
The ESM RB
The ESM RB is a savory delight featuring tender London broil and sweet caramelized Vidalia onions. We add a layer of horseradish cheddar cheese for a subtle spicy kick and then drizzle honey mustard for a touch of sweetness and tang. Served on a delicious pretzel roll, this sandwich offers a perfect balance of flavors and textures.
- Price: $12.00
The Southshire Shrimp
Seafood lovers will enjoy The Southshire Shrimp. Cajun spiced shrimp takes center stage in this flavorful sandwich, paired with crisp shredded iceberg lettuce and a creamy chipotle aioli for a smoky and slightly spicy finish. The pretzel roll adds a delightful chewiness that complements the shrimp perfectly.
- Price: $12.00
The Mad Hatter
Sometimes, the classics are the best. The Mad Hatter is our elevated take on the traditional BLT. Crispy bacon, shredded iceberg lettuce, and juicy tomatoes are layered on a pretzel roll and finished with mayonnaise. Simple, satisfying, and always delicious.
- Price: $12.00
The Wrestler (Vegetarian)
Vegetarian options can be just as exciting! The Wrestler is a flavorful and hearty vegetarian wrap featuring grilled portobello mushrooms and marinated artichoke hearts. We add refreshing cucumbers, red onions, and imported Swiss cheese. Hummus and pesto provide creamy and savory bases, creating a satisfying and nutritious vegetarian delight.
- Price: $11.50
The Mount Antonio (Vegetarian)
Another delicious vegetarian choice, The Mount Antonio, highlights fresh and simple Italian flavors. Fresh mozzarella cheese, ripe tomatoes, and fragrant fresh basil are layered on multigrain bread and dressed with balsamic vinaigrette. For those wanting to add protein, you can add meat for a slight upcharge.
- Price: $10.00 / Add Meat $12.00
The People’s Choice
Unleash your creativity with The People’s Choice! Dream up your perfect sandwich, and we’ll build it. Choose your favorite meats, cheeses, toppings, and dressings to create a truly personalized culinary experience. The possibilities are endless, and the deliciousness is guaranteed!
- Price: Starting at $12.00
Visit Elm Street Market today and experience the best deli sandwiches in town! We look forward to serving you.
