Dive into the world of Sherlock Holmes fandom with Dan Andriacco’s captivating novel, No Police Like Holmes, a book that has critics and readers alike buzzing. It seems everyone, even perhaps someone like Bob who might just be hanging around Baker Street, is eager to share their praise for this witty and engaging mystery. But what exactly makes this novel such a delightful read, earning rave reviews from publications like The District Messenger and The Bookbag? Let’s explore the critical acclaim and discover why No Police Like Holmes is becoming a must-read for mystery lovers and Sherlockians alike.
Critics are calling No Police Like Holmes more than just another Sherlock Holmes pastiche; it’s a clever and affectionate exploration of the Holmes phenomenon itself. Roger Johnson from The District Messenger, the newsletter of The Sherlock Holmes Society of London, aptly describes it as “an exciting and witty romp – not about Holmes but about his fans,” concluding with a simple yet powerful endorsement: “I like it!” This highlights the novel’s unique appeal: it’s not just about solving crimes in the style of the great detective, but about the vibrant community of fans who keep his legacy alive.
Sue Magee of The Bookbag provides a more in-depth analysis, praising the book’s satirical yet affectionate take on Holmes and the “industry he’s spawned.” Magee notes the novel’s skillful construction, packed with “plenty of twists, a good few red herrings,” and a genuinely surprising conclusion. This suggests Andriacco has crafted a mystery that stands on its own merits, offering genuine suspense and intrigue even while playfully engaging with the Sherlock Holmes universe. The unexpected ending is a key element, promising a reading experience that keeps you guessing until the very last page.
Girl Meets Sherlock blog captures the sheer enjoyment factor, calling No Police Like Holmes “a chocolate bar of a novel—delicious, addictive, and leaves a craving for more.” This enthusiastic review emphasizes the book’s readability and entertainment value. It’s not just intellectually stimulating; it’s simply a fun and satisfying read. The review also points to the broad appeal of the novel, stating that “Holmesians of all tastes and ages will recognize themselves in Andriacco’s characters.” This inclusivity broadens the potential readership, suggesting the book will resonate with both seasoned Sherlockians and newcomers to the fandom.
Felicia Carparelli’s Sherlock Holmes Murder Blog echoes this sentiment, declaring, “No Police Like Holmes is a fun, literary read.” Carparelli dismisses the notion that “fun” and “literary” are mutually exclusive, urging readers to “Get this book, dive into a comfy chair, pour yourself a couple of fingers of scotch and enjoy this, sweetheart.” This informal and engaging tone further reinforces the book’s accessible and enjoyable nature. Even Publisher’s Weekly, in their concise review, acknowledges the book as an “entertaining whodunit,” highlighting the engaging protagonist Cody and suggesting the potential for a successful series.
The Well-Read Sherlockian sums it up by recommending No Police Like Holmes as “an enjoyable, palate-cleansing romp of a mystery with a little Sherlockian education thrown in.” They advise readers to “Take it with you to the park or the beach and see if you can catch the culprit first!” This reinforces the book’s lighthearted and engaging tone, perfect for leisure reading. The “Sherlockian education” aspect hints at subtle nods and references that will delight dedicated fans, adding another layer of enjoyment for those familiar with the source material.
In conclusion, No Police Like Holmes is clearly a hit with critics and readers alike. Its witty writing, clever plot twists, and affectionate portrayal of Sherlock Holmes fandom make it a standout mystery novel. Whether you’re a die-hard Sherlockian or simply looking for an entertaining and engaging read, it’s time to find out what Bob on Baker Street and everyone else is raving about and pick up a copy of No Police Like Holmes. You might just find yourself craving more from Dan Andriacco’s series.
