Cherry Street Pub in Lancaster, Ohio, is your go-to destination for mouthwatering burgers and sandwiches crafted with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Our commitment to quality starts with our ground chuck, freshly ground daily, ensuring every burger is packed with flavor. Prepared medium to medium-well and accompanied by classic fries and pickles, our burgers are a satisfying meal any time of day. For those seeking a lighter option, transform any burger into a Burger Bowl – a delicious salad alternative, bun and fries free of charge. Beyond burgers, our menu boasts a diverse selection of sandwiches, each served with fries and pickles, unless specified otherwise, promising a delightful culinary experience at Cherry Street Pub.
Burger Selections at Cherry Street Pub
Indulge in our wide array of burger creations, each offering a unique flavor profile to tantalize your taste buds. For burger enthusiasts looking to customize, we offer the option to substitute bison for any burger for an additional 8.00, or choose a gluten-free (GF) bun for just 2.00 extra.
ALL AMERICAN* – A timeless classic, our double cheeseburger features two patties layered with cheese on a brioche roll, topped with fresh lettuce, tomato, and onion (LTO). Priced at 13.75, it’s a hearty and satisfying choice.
BABB***** – Dare to try the Bad @$$ Beef Burger! This indulgent creation combines sautéed onions and mushrooms, creamy blue cheese, a tangy A-1 sauce, and a sinful mayo for a truly unforgettable burger experience at 16.99.
BAYOU BURGER***** – Spice things up with our Bayou Burger. Cajun seasoned ground beef is topped with crisp lettuce, spicy pepper jack cheese, crispy cotton onions, and a smoky BBQ sauce, all for 16.50.
MUSHMONSTER* – Mushroom lovers, rejoice! The Mushmonster is a 1/2lb burger loaded with mushrooms, Swiss and gouda cheeses, Worcestershire sauce, lettuce, and a flavorful garlic aioli, priced at 16.50.
FRENCH ONION BURGER* – For a sophisticated twist, try our French Onion Burger. This fork-and-knife rosemary burger is served on a toasted bun, smothered in sweet onion bisque, and generously topped with melted Swiss and mozzarella cheeses for 15.99. Please note, the French Onion Burger is not available as a bowl option.
THE HANGOVER BURGER ***** – Cure your cravings with The Hangover Burger. A cheeseburger served open-faced on Texas toast, topped with crispy bacon and a perfectly cooked over-easy egg. Served with tater tots for 15.99. For an extra indulgence, add grilled bologna for just 1.99.
QUITE-A-GOUDA BURGER* – Double the deliciousness with the Quite-A-Gouda Burger. This double burger features crispy bacon, sweet caramelized onions, creamy gouda cheese, and fresh lettuce, all for 14.99.
THE BEAST* – Prepare to conquer The Beast! This 1/2 lb burger is piled high with gouda, American, and mozzarella cheeses, cherrywood bacon, cotton onions, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, mayo, disco sauce, and a fried egg. At 14.99, it’s a meal in itself and doesn’t come with a side – because it simply doesn’t need one.
B*TCHIN’ TRIPLE CHEESE TRIPLE BACON BURGER* – Go big or go home with the B*tchin’ Triple Cheese Triple Bacon Burger. A 1/2 lb burger topped with 3 slices of American cheese, 3 strips of bacon, and a drizzle of BBQ and mayo for 14.99.
BLACK BEAN BURGER – Vegetarian diners will love our house-made Black Bean Burger. A flavorful black bean patty served on a toasted bun with lettuce, creamy avocado spread, fresh corn salsa, and a zesty chipotle sauce for 15.25. (Please note: This burger is vegetarian but cannot be made vegan).
CHEESEBURGER WRAP – Enjoy burger flavors in a unique way with our Cheeseburger Wrap. A generous 1/2 pound of ground beef, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, onion, & pickles, and 1000 island dressing, all wrapped up and grilled to perfection for 15.25.
BIG MAX BURGER – For the ultimate burger experience, try the Big Max Burger. Double patties are piled high with American cheese, shredded lettuce, diced red onion, and a flavorful combination of Sriracha & disco sauce for 17.99.
Sandwiches and Wraps at Cherry Street Pub
Beyond our exceptional burgers, Cherry Street Pub offers a variety of sandwiches and wraps, perfect for lunch or dinner.
THAI CHICKEN WRAP***** – Experience the flavors of the East with our Thai Chicken Wrap. Pecan chicken is combined with a sweet chili sauce, crisp lettuce, Asian slaw, red onions, and crunchy peanuts for 12.95.
REUBEN* – A classic done right. Our Reuben features tender corned beef, Swiss cheese, tangy 1000 Island dressing, and sauerkraut, grilled to perfection on marble rye bread for 13.25.
BEER BATTERED COD* – Seafood lovers will appreciate our Beer Battered Cod sandwich. Flaky cod on a brioche roll with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and tartar sauce for 12.50.
SOUTHERN SIMPLE***** – Savor the taste of the South with our Southern Simple sandwich. Buttermilk fried chicken, shredded lettuce, mayo, and pickles served on a brioche roll for 12.95.
BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH***** – For a spicy kick, try our Buffalo Chicken Sandwich. Fried chicken tossed in mild buffalo sauce, topped with lettuce, red onion, and tomato on a brioche roll, with blue cheese dressing on the side for 13.25.
FRIED BOLOGNA SANDWICH – A hearty and flavorful option, our Fried Bologna Sandwich features thick sliced, German style bologna, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, grilled jalapenos & grilled onions for 13.25.
PUB CLUB – A lunchtime staple, the Pub Club is stacked with turkey, ham, bacon, lettuce, tomato, American cheese, and herb mayo on 9-grain toast for 12.95.
CHICKEN BACON CHIPOTLE MELT – Indulge in our Chicken Bacon Chipotle Melt. Our simple chicken on buttered & grilled 9-grain bread, topped with melted Swiss & parmesan cheeses, crispy bacon & a creamy chipotle sauce for 14.25.
Visit Cherry Street Pub in Lancaster, Ohio, today and discover your new favorite burger or sandwich!
