Taylor Street in Chicago’s Little Italy/University Village neighborhood is a vibrant tapestry of history and culinary tradition. For generations, this historic enclave has been a cornerstone of Chicago’s Italian-American heritage, boasting a rich collection of homes, shops, and, most notably, restaurants that have become integral parts of the community’s fabric. Beyond its Italian roots, Taylor Street has evolved into a diverse dining destination, offering an exciting mix of culinary experiences that cater to a wide range of tastes. From classic Italian fare to global flavors, cozy cafes, and bustling bakeries, Taylor Street presents a delightful exploration for any food enthusiast.
Taylor Street in Chicago's Little Italy, showcasing historic buildings and vibrant street life
For years, I’ve personally enjoyed the evolving restaurant scene on Taylor Street, witnessing both cherished establishments and exciting new additions. While some spots have sadly closed their doors, the overall culinary landscape has only become richer and more diverse. Today, you can find everything from a perfect cup of coffee and artisanal pastries to authentic Indian, Thai, Portuguese, and French cuisine, all alongside the traditional Italian dishes and refreshing Italian ice that define the neighborhood’s culinary identity. Let’s explore some of the standout Chicago Taylor Street Restaurants that make this neighborhood a must-visit for food lovers.
Iconic Bakeries and Sweet Treats on Taylor Street
Taylor Street boasts some truly iconic bakeries, each with its own unique charm and history. These are the places where you can indulge in classic Italian pastries, freshly baked bread, and delightful sweet treats.
Scafuri Bakery: A Century-Old Neighborhood Gem
Scafuri Bakery, a true neighborhood institution, has been serving the community since 1904. Stepping inside is like stepping back in time, greeted by the aroma of freshly baked goods and the warm, inviting atmosphere. Whether you’re looking for a morning coffee and pastry, a perfectly crafted cookie, or a decadent pie, Scafuri’s is the place to go. On my recent visit, their oatmeal raisin cookie was a standout – perfectly chewy and flavorful. Everything at Scafuri’s, from their elaborate cakes to simple cookies and pastries, is made in-house with time-honored recipes and a commitment to quality.
Display case filled with delicious pastries and cookies at Scafuri Bakery on Taylor Street in Chicago
Original Ferrara Bakery & Cafe: A Taste of Italian Heritage Since 1908
Just a short distance west of Little Italy, in the Tri-Taylor neighborhood, you’ll find the Original Ferrara Bakery & Cafe. This classic Italian bakery and restaurant, family-owned and operated since 1908, is a testament to the enduring legacy of Italian pastry making in Chicago. Salvatore Ferrara, the founder, brought his pastry skills from Nola, Italy, and quickly established himself as a purveyor of fine pastries and confections on Taylor Street. Ferrara Bakery not only created beloved local treats but also launched the Ferrara Pan Candy Company, responsible for worldwide favorites like Lemonheads and Atomic Fireballs.
Exterior of Original Ferrara Bakery & Cafe on Taylor Street, a historic Italian bakery in Chicago
Today, Ferrara Bakery offers an extensive menu of cakes, custom creations, pastries, cookies, and their famous cannoli. Beyond the sweets, they also have a savory food menu featuring sandwiches, pasta, pizza, and entrees. During my visit, I thoroughly enjoyed their caprese sandwich, a delightful combination of fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, and pesto aioli on toasted French bread. To complete the experience, I indulged in a cappuccino and an assortment of their buttery, melt-in-your-mouth cookies. Ferrara Bakery is more than just a bakery; it’s a culinary experience and a piece of Chicago history.
Assortment of colorful Italian cookies and pastries displayed at Original Ferrara Bakery & Cafe in Chicago
Mario’s Italian Lemonade: A Summer Tradition Since 1954
For a quintessential Chicago summer treat, Mario’s Italian Lemonade is an absolute must-visit. Since 1954, this Taylor Street institution has been serving up refreshing Italian ices, becoming a beloved tradition for locals and visitors alike. When the weather warms up, there’s no better way to cool down than with a flavorful Italian ice from Mario’s.
Mario's Italian Lemonade stand on Taylor Street in Chicago, a popular spot for summer refreshments
Brunch and Comfort Food Favorites
If you’re seeking a hearty brunch or classic comfort food in a welcoming atmosphere, Taylor Street has several excellent options.
Sweet Maple Cafe: Country Comfort and Local Charm
Right next door to Scafuri Bakery, you’ll find Sweet Maple Cafe, a local favorite known for its country-style comfort food and all-day breakfasts. After hearing rave reviews, I made my way there for a Sunday brunch and was immediately charmed by the friendly atmosphere and delicious food. Sweet Maple Cafe’s menu features everything from fluffy pancakes and savory omelets to hearty lunch options. Their biscuits are particularly noteworthy – light, buttery, and the perfect accompaniment to any breakfast dish. For over 20 years, Sweet Maple Cafe has cultivated a loyal local following, drawn to its excellent food, warm service, and genuine neighborhood feel.
Cozy interior of Sweet Maple Cafe on Taylor Street, filled with patrons enjoying brunch
Demitasse Cafe: Diner-Style Breakfast and Lunch
Next door to Mario’s Italian Lemonade is Demitasse Cafe, a classic diner-style spot that offers a comforting menu of coffee, breakfast, and lunch dishes. If you’re in the mood for a no-fuss, satisfying meal in a casual setting, Demitasse Cafe is a solid choice.
Exterior of Demitasse Cafe on Taylor Street, a diner-style restaurant in Chicago's Little Italy
Stax Cafe: Local Breakfast Recommendation
While I haven’t personally visited Stax Cafe yet, it comes highly recommended for breakfast by Taylor Street locals. Located further down Taylor Street, it’s worth checking out if you’re looking for another breakfast option with local approval.
Classic Italian Dining and Trattorias
No exploration of Chicago Taylor Street restaurants would be complete without highlighting its traditional Italian eateries. These restaurants are the heart of Little Italy, serving up authentic flavors and time-honored recipes.
Chez Joel: French Bistro Charm in Little Italy
For a delightful surprise, Chez Joel brings the charm of a French bistro to the heart of Little Italy. This wonderful restaurant offers a traditional French dining experience in a cozy setting. I’ve always enjoyed the food at Chez Joel and highly recommend it. In warmer months, their lovely patio provides an enchanting outdoor dining option.
Elegant dining room of Chez Joel French Bistro on Taylor Street in Chicago
Tuscany on Taylor: Tuscan-Inspired Italian Cuisine
Tuscany on Taylor offers a more upscale Italian dining experience, specializing in Tuscan-inspired seafood, pasta dishes, and wood-fired pizzas. This traditional trattoria is a great spot for a more formal Italian meal, complete with a selection of Italian wines.
Tufano’s Vernon Park Tap: A James Beard Award Winner with Deep Roots
For a truly authentic and historic Italian experience, Tufano’s Vernon Park Tap is a must. Established in 1930, this family-run restaurant has been serving traditional Italian specialties for nearly a century. Finding these long-standing, neighborhood spots is always a treat, and Tufano’s is no exception. On my recent lunch visit, I savored their chicken picante and delicious tiramisu, complemented by excellent service. Tufano’s also boasts a large outdoor patio for al fresco dining. Adding to its accolades, Tufano’s received the prestigious American Classics Award from the James Beard Foundation in 2008, solidifying its place as a culinary landmark.
Exterior of Tufano's Vernon Park Tap on Taylor Street, a historic Italian restaurant in Chicago
Pompeii: A Neighborhood Staple Since 1909
Another long-standing Italian establishment, Pompeii has been a part of the Taylor Street neighborhood since 1909. While I haven’t personally visited Pompeii recently, its longevity speaks volumes about its place in the community and its enduring appeal.
Exploring Global Flavors on Taylor Street
Beyond Italian cuisine, Taylor Street offers a taste of international flavors, reflecting the neighborhood’s evolving and diverse culinary scene.
County Barbecue: Smoked Meats and Southern Comfort
For a departure from Italian fare, County Barbecue brings the flavors of Southern barbecue to Taylor Street. Located on Taylor Street, County Barbecue offers a menu of smoked meats, classic barbecue sides, and a taste of Southern comfort food.
Plates of barbecue ribs and sides at County Barbecue on Taylor Street in Chicago
Kurimu: Asian-Inspired Tea and Ice Cream
Kurimu offers a unique and modern twist to the Taylor Street dining scene with its Asian-inspired tea and ice cream creations. If you’re looking for something different and refreshing, Kurimu is worth exploring.
Beyond Restaurants: Conte de Savoia Italian Market
While not a restaurant, Conte de Savoia Italian market is an essential part of the Taylor Street experience. This neighborhood staple since 1948 offers a deli with sandwiches, subs, and salads, along with a wide selection of imported Italian products. It’s the perfect place to pick up ingredients for your own Italian cooking or to grab a quick and delicious Italian-style lunch.
Conte de Savoia Italian Market storefront on Taylor Street in Chicago, a neighborhood Italian deli and grocery
Taylor Street: A Culinary Destination with History
Taylor Street is more than just a collection of restaurants; it’s a vibrant neighborhood with a rich history and a dynamic culinary scene. From iconic bakeries and classic Italian trattorias to diverse global flavors, Chicago Taylor Street restaurants offer something for every palate. Exploring this historic street is a true culinary journey, inviting you to savor the flavors of the past and discover the exciting tastes of the present. Make sure to visit Taylor Street and experience the delicious heart of Chicago’s Little Italy.
