“The Confession,” an episode of Friday Night Lights, surprisingly downplayed Landry Clarke’s guilt admission, despite the title and network promotion. While Landry’s storyline contained the episode’s strongest moments, particularly featuring Jesse Plemons and Glenn Morshower, other storylines, like the Julie-Tami conflict and those of Jason Street and Tim Riggins, were less successful.
The limited screen time for Landry’s plot felt detrimental, hindering the potential of Plemons and Morshower’s performances. Plemons’ acting was crucial, adding depth beyond the script. Given the self-defense aspect and the Texas setting, Landry’s prosecution seemed improbable. His father’s law enforcement background further reduced this likelihood. Landry’s intelligence should have made him aware of this, as should his father. Landry’s insistence on punishment reflects his character—taking a life is significant for him, akin to a soldier’s burden. While Landry’s desire for punishment might seem unconvincing on paper, Plemons portrayed it as self-brainwashing. His eventual agreement with his father and attorney appeared motivated by a desire to protect his parents and Tyra from further suffering. Despite the storyline’s resolution, Landry’s final look suggested a lasting burden.
Jason Street’s return after a two-week absence introduced a questionable plot development. The idea of him finding a wheelchair fetishist on a dating site in Dillon, a town seemingly small, strains credibility. The added detail of this woman also having a water sports fetish and being unaware of Street makes the scenario even more improbable. In a larger city, this might be plausible, but Dillon’s portrayal as a smaller town makes it unbelievable. There were more credible ways to connect Jason with the waitress and establish his living arrangement with Herc without resorting to this comedic and far-fetched setup.
Regarding comedy, the scene with Matt and Carlotta interrupted by Grandma Saracen could have easily been awkward. However, effective acting and editing made it feel authentic to the characters, avoiding a typical teen comedy cliché. Similarly, Smash’s anticipation of a romantic encounter with Carlotta, only to find she was looking for Matt, was humorous because it played on established character traits. Friday Night Lights rarely uses comic relief, but when it does, it succeeds by grounding it in character development.
Tim Riggins’ crazy-roommate storyline resurfaced, eliciting mixed reactions. While a storyline of Riggins living with the Taylors was anticipated in the first season, its occurrence now, linked to his struggle to rejoin the team, makes more sense. Coach Taylor’s demand for Riggins to earn his team spot is commendable. However, connecting it to the roommate plot feels disjointed, as if the writers are unsure whether to aim for comedy or suspense. The roommate’s menacing presence at the gymnastics meet was engaging, but after Landry’s extended storyline, concerns arise about this plotline becoming prolonged and potentially melodramatic, especially considering the roommate’s instability and drug use. Following Landry’s storyline, similar thematic territory feels premature.
Santiago and Buddy’s storyline remains a highlight of season two. However, Santiago’s emotional scene in the pickup truck had strong Good Will Hunting echoes. His success with the Panthers on the field was unexpected and the game was a well-executed football sequence. The most notable scene not yet discussed is the Julie-Tami confrontation, their most dramatic yet. It showcased Connie Britton’s acting but also highlighted Coach Taylor’s reduced role since returning to Dillon. Connecting him to Landry’s storyline, perhaps with scenes between Coach Taylor and Morshower, would have been beneficial, given the under-explored impact of Landry’s confession on the Panthers. Friday Night Lights entered the writers’ strike with a substantial episode reserve. With six episodes remaining, anticipation builds for the series’ return in 2008. Kyle Chandler’s importance to the show is evident, and hopefully, he will assume a more central role in the upcoming episodes.
For more recaps of Friday Night Lights, click here.
This article was originally published on The House Next Door.
If you can, please consider supporting Slant Magazine. Since 2001, we’ve provided candid reviews of film, music, television, video games, theater, and more. Independent publications like Slant face challenges, but we are dedicated to keeping content accessible without paywalls. Support us through Patreon or by making a donation.
