There’s a charming anecdote swirling around the production of the 1947 film, “Miracle On 34th Street,” recently highlighted by AMC. Legend has it that after filming wrapped, 20th Century Fox had to submit the movie for approval to the heads of both Macy’s and Gimbel’s department stores. Failure to secure their endorsement, it was said, could have forced costly rewrites and reshoots. However, considering a significant portion of “Miracle” was filmed inside Macy’s flagship store in New York City – not to mention the inherent risk-averse nature of studio executives even back then – this tale likely leans more towards studio publicity than actual fact.
Fortunately, this bit of manufactured drama is the only hint of inauthenticity associated with this cinematic gem. “Miracle On 34th Street” truly lives up to its name; it’s a miracle of filmmaking.
The film’s enduring magic begins with its brilliantly crafted and deeply thoughtful screenplay. Couple this with an absolutely flawless cast – every role, big or small, is perfectly filled. Even a brief, uncredited appearance like Thelma Ritter as “Peter’s Mother” leaves a lasting impression. Adding to the film’s genuine feel is its on-location shooting. Beyond Macy’s, the movie incorporates footage from the actual 1946 Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade, a real post office facility, and a courthouse, lending a powerful sense of realism. And then there’s Edmund Gwenn’s Oscar-winning performance, which effortlessly rekindles your belief in Santa Claus, whether you anticipated it or not.
“Miracle On 34th Street” resonates on multiple levels. It’s a vibrant celebration of the Christmas spirit, a poignant commentary on the growing commercialism of Christmas even in the post-war era of 1947, and a profound exploration of faith and belief. Directed by George Seaton, the film, starring Maureen O’Hara and a young Natalie Wood alongside Gwenn, seamlessly blends heartwarming sentiment with sharp wit.
Even now, decades after its original release, “Miracle On 34th Street” retains every ounce of its charm and impact. When seeking the definitive version of this heartwarming tale, bypass the numerous remakes – both made-for-TV and theatrical – and especially avoid mentioning the ill-fated 1963 Broadway musical adaptation, “Here’s Love.”
Seek out the original 1947 film. Choose the genuine “Miracle On 34th Street”. Watch it, and rediscover its enchantment, year after year.
