Street Prostitution is a complex issue that affects communities worldwide. It’s characterized by visible street-based sex work, leading to a range of social problems, from nuisance and public disorder to serious crime and exploitation. Tackling street prostitution effectively requires a nuanced and multi-faceted approach, moving beyond simple law enforcement tactics to address the root causes and contributing factors. This guide, based on comprehensive research, outlines various responses to street prostitution, analyzing their mechanisms, ideal conditions for success, and key considerations for implementation. Understanding these different strategies is crucial for developing effective, sustainable solutions tailored to specific local contexts.
| Deterring Prostitutes and Clients |
|---|
| Response 1: Enforcing Laws Against Soliciting, Patronizing, and Loitering |
| How It Works: Increased law enforcement targeting soliciting, patronizing, and loitering aims to temporarily remove both sex workers and clients from the streets. This immediate action disrupts the visible market and can provide a sense of immediate relief to affected communities. |
| Works Best If: This approach is most effective when coupled with comprehensive follow-up programs designed to support sex workers in exiting the industry or transitioning to safer, indoor venues. Furthermore, its impact is amplified when integrated with other proactive and preventative strategies. |
| Considerations: While enforcement can offer a short-term fix, it’s an expensive strategy with limited long-term impact. Displacement is a significant concern, as enforcement efforts may simply shift the problem to neighboring areas. Additionally, fines imposed on sex workers can inadvertently create a cycle of vulnerability, compelling them to engage in more sex work to meet financial penalties. |
| Response 1a: Enforcing Laws Prohibiting Prostitution and Solicitation |
| How It Works: Direct enforcement against prostitution itself, alongside solicitation, aims to increase the risks and costs associated with the trade. Arresting clients, in particular, can act as a deterrent, especially if sanctions are meaningful. |
| Works Best If: Meaningful sanctions for sex workers are in place, and the pool of potential clients is relatively small. This targeted approach can be more impactful in environments where client demand is less robust. |
| Considerations: Securing admissible evidence for prostitution charges can be challenging and resource-intensive. Jail time for prostitution offenses is often limited or non-existent, diminishing the deterrent effect. Furthermore, aggressive enforcement can discourage sex workers from reporting crimes against them to the police, creating a climate of mistrust. The financial strain of fines can also push individuals further into prostitution. Prosecutorial discretion may lead to reluctance in pursuing prostitution cases. General deterrence through client arrests is difficult to achieve if the potential client base is large. Arresting clients may require dedicated female officers, and undercover operations can be unpopular within police departments. |
| Response 1b: Enforcing Laws Against Conduct Associated with Prostitution |
| How It Works: This strategy focuses on deterring prostitution-related activities, such as loitering or visible displays of solicitation, without requiring direct proof of sexual transactions. This can proactively disrupt the street market by targeting preparatory behaviors. |
| Works Best If: Meaningful sanctions can be applied, and the client pool is relatively small. This approach is similar to 1a in its targeted deterrence. |
| Considerations: The legality of such laws can be contested, with courts sometimes striking them down for being overly vague or broad. General deterrence through arrests alone remains difficult to achieve with a large potential client base. |
| Response 1c: Intensive Short-Term Enforcement Campaigns |
| How It Works: Concentrated, short bursts of intensive law enforcement activity aim to temporarily suppress street prostitution and deter potential clients from the area. The visibility of these campaigns is key to their deterrent effect. |
| Works Best If: Campaigns are accompanied by media coverage to amplify the message and are followed by environmental changes in the area to prevent a quick return to previous patterns. |
| Considerations: Media coverage can inadvertently advertise prostitution locations, potentially attracting more activity. Displacing sex workers to unfamiliar areas can increase their vulnerability and risk of harm. |
| Response 2: Establishing Highly Visible Police Presence |
| How It Works: A consistent and visible police presence can deter both sex workers and clients from engaging in negotiations in a particular area. The perception of increased risk can disrupt the street market. |
| Works Best If: Visible presence is sustained and combined with environmental changes to reinforce the message and prevent the problem from resurfacing once police presence is reduced. |
| Considerations: Maintaining a highly visible police presence is labor-intensive and resource-demanding. It can also create a perception that the area is unsafe, potentially impacting legitimate businesses and residents. |
| Response 3: Relaxing Regulation of Indoor Prostitution Venues |
| How It Works: Loosening regulations on indoor venues may incentivize street-based sex workers to relocate to these safer, more controlled environments. This can reduce the visibility of street prostitution and associated public order issues. |
| Works Best If: Street sex workers are willing and able to transition to indoor work. This requires ensuring indoor options are accessible and viable for those currently working on the streets. |
| Considerations: Relaxing regulations can be perceived as condoning prostitution, which may face public opposition. Concerns also arise regarding police oversight of indoor venues and the potential for exploitation and trafficking within these settings. |
| Response 4: Enhanced Penalties in High-Activity Zones |
| How It Works: Increasing fines and penalties for prostitution-related offenses specifically within designated high-activity zones aims to displace the street prostitution market from those targeted areas. The increased risk and cost can make these zones less attractive. |
| Works Best If: Enhanced penalties are coupled with environmental changes to prevent the displaced activity from simply returning once enforcement pressure eases. |
| Considerations: Displacement is a primary concern. The problem may simply shift to areas where the impact is even more detrimental or less manageable. |
| Response 5: Banning Prostitutes or Clients from Certain Areas |
| How It Works: Area bans restrict the opportunities for sex workers and clients to meet and engage in solicitation and patronage within defined zones. This geographically limits the market’s operational space. |
| Works Best If: Bans are adequately monitored, and clear physical descriptions of offenders are available for enforcement. Legal authority for implementing and enforcing bans is also essential. |
| Considerations: Legal authority is required to implement such bans. Displacement remains a risk, potentially pushing sex workers into more hazardous, remote locations. |
| Response 6: Community Justice Panels and Community Service |
| How It Works: Utilizing community justice panels and community service sentences offers meaningful consequences for both sex workers and clients, diverting them from incarceration or fines. Community service consumes time and can provide restorative justice opportunities. |
| Works Best If: Compliance with sentences is adequately monitored, and community members are willing to participate in justice panels. Community involvement is crucial for the success of this approach. |
| Considerations: Requires ongoing monitoring by courts and corrections officials to ensure compliance and effectiveness. |
| Response 7: Community Surveillance and Public Protest |
| How It Works: Community involvement in surveillance and public protests can create a perception of constant monitoring and reporting, increasing pressure on public officials to address street prostitution. Public disapproval can deter both sex workers and clients. |
| Works Best If: The community is willing to sustain protests lawfully, and police provide supervision and oversight to prevent vigilantism. Committed leadership is needed to organize and mobilize community members. |
| Considerations: Risks of overzealousness and vigilantism are present. Displacement to other locations remains a possibility. Sustained community involvement requires dedicated leaders to recruit, organize, and maintain momentum. |
| Response 8: Education and Warnings for High-Risk Populations |
| How It Works: Education programs targeted at young people and potential clients aim to deter entry into prostitution and discourage patronage. Education for arrested clients can reduce recidivism by addressing underlying issues and consequences. |
| Works Best If: Evidence indicates recruitment of sex workers from specific populations, messages are tailored to the target audience, and resources are available to run effective education programs. |
| Considerations: Young people at high risk often face multiple complex social problems requiring comprehensive intervention beyond just education. Running effective programs is costly. Deterrence may be achieved through various forms of intervention, not solely education. School-based programs may not reach clients at the highest risk of perpetrating violence. |
| Targeting Prostitutes |
|---|
| Response 9: Restraining Orders/Civil Injunctions Against Habitual Prostitutes |
| How It Works: Civil injunctions target chronic offenders, controlling and deterring their activities in specific areas. This can be a resource-efficient approach, focusing on the most problematic individuals. |
| Works Best If: Complainants are willing to file for court orders, and the number of chronic offenders is relatively small. This approach is best suited for dealing with repeat offenders causing significant disruption. |
| Considerations: Documenting individuals and their activities is labor-intensive and costly. Legality varies by jurisdiction, and the legal framework for civil injunctions must be in place. |
| Response 10: Mediating Conflicts Between Prostitutes and the Community |
| How It Works: Mediation seeks to resolve conflicts by negotiating agreements between sex workers and community members. This can involve sex workers agreeing to avoid certain areas or behaviors in exchange for community tolerance. |
| Works Best If: The community is willing to tolerate some level of street prostitution and engage in constructive dialogue. |
| Considerations: Getting sex workers to adhere to agreements can be challenging, requiring ongoing communication and monitoring. |
| Response 11: Imposing Curfews on Prostitutes |
| How It Works: Curfews restrict sex workers’ operating hours, reducing activity during specific periods, often nighttime hours when complaints are highest. |
| Works Best If: Street prostitution is most prevalent during specific, predictable periods. Curfews can target these peak times. |
| Considerations: Requires a judicial order as a condition of bail or probation, limiting its broad applicability. Enforcement requires monitoring by police or corrections officials. |
| Response 12: Helping Prostitutes to Quit |
| How It Works: Providing support services, such as counseling, job training, and housing assistance, empowers sex workers to exit the industry. Health services, including STI screening and education, are also crucial. |
| Works Best If: Programs are specifically tailored to the needs of sex workers, easily accessible, and integrated with sanctions for non-compliance to incentivize participation. |
| Considerations: Persuading street sex workers, especially juveniles and those controlled by pimps, to engage with support services can be difficult. Privacy concerns and fear of losing child custody can also be barriers to accessing help. Outreach and trust-building are essential. |
| Response 13: Encouraging Prostitutes to Report Serious Offenses |
| How It Works: Building trust between police and sex workers encourages reporting of serious crimes that might otherwise go unreported, improving police investigations and victim support. |
| Works Best If: Police can establish a sufficient level of trust with sex workers, ensuring their safety and confidentiality. |
| Considerations: Providing evidence against pimps can significantly increase the risk of violent retaliation for sex workers. Witness protection and support are crucial. |
| Response 14: Helping Prostitutes Avoid Dangerous Clients and Situations |
| How It Works: Educating sex workers on safety strategies and providing resources to avoid dangerous clients and situations can reduce the risk of physical assault and harm. |
| Works Best If: Police can build trust with sex workers and deliver effective safety information. |
| Considerations: Police involvement in providing safety advice can be misconstrued as condoning prostitution. Clear messaging and ethical considerations are important. |
| Targeting Clients |
|---|
| Response 15: Exposing Clients to Publicity |
| How It Works: Publicizing the identities of arrested clients aims to shame them and deter re-offending, as well as discourage potential clients. Social stigma can be a powerful deterrent. |
| Works Best If: The community and media support public shaming, and most clients solicit from vehicles, making identification easier. |
| Considerations: Media outlets may be reluctant to publicize such information, deeming it unnewsworthy. Risks of misidentification and harming innocent individuals exist. Legal restrictions and privacy concerns must be carefully considered. Geographic displacement may occur. The deterrent effect may diminish after initial exposures. |
| Response 16: Notifying Those with Influence Over Clients’ Conduct |
| How It Works: Informing individuals who have influence over clients, such as family members, employers, or community leaders, creates meaningful social consequences for their behavior. Informal social controls can be very effective. |
| Works Best If: Clients are influenced by informal social controls and their actions are likely to be viewed negatively by their social circles. |
| Considerations: The penalty, such as job loss, may be perceived as disproportionately harsh by some. Ethical considerations and potential for unintended consequences need to be weighed. |
| Response 17: Restricting Clients’ Ability to Drive |
| How It Works: Suspending or revoking driver’s licenses for prostitution-related offenses, particularly curb-crawling, aims to deter clients who rely on vehicles to solicit sex workers. |
| Works Best If: Most clients solicit from vehicles. This strategy directly targets vehicle-based solicitation. |
| Considerations: Legal challenges and restrictions may arise. Compliance rates with license suspensions and revocations can be low, requiring robust enforcement mechanisms. |
| Changing the Environment |
|---|
| Response 18: Closing Streets and Alleys, Diverting Traffic, or Regulating Parking |
| How It Works: Environmental modifications that increase the difficulty for clients to find and negotiate with sex workers disrupt the accessibility and convenience of the street prostitution market. |
| Works Best If: The affected community supports the changes, and most clients solicit from vehicles, making traffic and parking regulations impactful. |
| Considerations: These measures can be costly and may negatively impact residential and legitimate commercial traffic. They could also inadvertently create inaccessible enclaves, locking the problem in rather than displacing it. Slowing traffic may paradoxically facilitate curb-crawling. |
| Response 19: Enforcing Zoning, Nuisance Abatement, and Business License Regulations |
| How It Works: Targeting properties used for prostitution through zoning and nuisance laws restricts the availability of locations for sexual activities, deterring the use of motels and hotels for prostitution. |
| Works Best If: Sexual transactions frequently occur on properties subject to such regulations, allowing for targeted intervention. |
| Considerations: Civil law processes can be complex and unfamiliar to law enforcement. Support from government lawyers is essential for navigating these processes. |
| Response 20: Warning Property Owners About Prostitution on Their Premises |
| How It Works: Informing property owners about prostitution-related activities on their property can encourage them to take action to prevent it, increasing their capacity and willingness to control illegal activities. |
| Works Best If: Sexual transactions occur on these properties, and property owners are responsive to warnings and willing to cooperate. |
| Considerations: Property owners may feel unfairly accused or may be reluctant to take action due to fear of retaliation or involvement. |
| Response 21: Redeveloping the Area Economy |
| How It Works: Economic redevelopment promotes legitimate economic activity, displacing illicit activities like street prostitution by changing the social and economic landscape of the area. |
| Works Best If: Improvements substantially alter the conditions that allow street prostitution to flourish, addressing root causes and creating alternative opportunities. |
| Considerations: Redevelopment is costly and time-consuming in the short term. Displacement to more vulnerable areas remains a potential risk during the transition. |
| Response 22: Securing Abandoned Buildings |
| How It Works: Securing abandoned buildings eliminates private spaces used for sexual transactions, reducing the opportunities for street prostitution to occur discreetly. |
| Works Best If: Sexual transactions commonly take place in abandoned buildings in the target area. |
| Considerations: Securing buildings incurs costs. Displacement to other locations, including other unsecured buildings, is possible. |
| Response 23: Enhancing Surveillance with Improved Lighting and CCTV |
| How It Works: Improved lighting and CCTV enhance natural surveillance, deterring prostitution by increasing the perceived risk of detection and improving the area’s overall appearance and safety. |
| Works Best If: Lighting is currently inadequate, and sexual transactions occur in dark, secluded places. |
| Considerations: Installation and maintenance of lighting and CCTV are costly. Enhanced lighting may paradoxically increase perceptions of safety, drawing more activity, including both legitimate and illegitimate. |
| Response 24: Providing Trash Cans |
| How It Works: Providing trash cans encourages the proper disposal of hazardous waste associated with street prostitution, such as condoms and needles, improving public health and neighborhood aesthetics. |
| Works Best If: Trash cans are placed strategically near locations where sexual transactions occur. |
| Considerations: Trash cans must be emptied regularly to be effective. Police may face accusations of condoning prostitution by providing such amenities in areas known for sex work. |
| Responses With Limited Effectiveness |
|---|
| Response 25: Conducting Sweeps |
| How It Works: Sweeps involve mass arrests of sex workers and clients, temporarily removing them from the streets. |
| Works Best If: N/A – Sweeps are generally ineffective and counterproductive. |
| Considerations: Sweeps undermine the criminal justice system and police integrity due to their indiscriminate nature and low long-term impact. They carry a high risk of arresting innocent individuals. |
| Response 26: Harassing and Intimidating Prostitutes |
| How It Works: Harassment and intimidation tactics aim to discourage sex workers from operating in a specific area. |
| Works Best If: N/A – Harassment and intimidation are unethical and ineffective strategies. |
| Considerations: Undermines police integrity and erodes public trust. Geographically displaces the problem without addressing root causes. Human rights violations are a serious concern. |
| Response 27: Suspending or Revoking Government Aid to Prostitutes |
| How It Works: Withholding government aid is intended to pressure sex workers to quit prostitution by removing a source of income or support. |
| Works Best If: Sex workers are receiving significant government aid without reporting prostitution income, and aid agencies are willing to take punitive action. |
| Considerations: Implications for dependent children must be considered. Adequate social service follow-up is essential to prevent further hardship. This approach may have the opposite effect, compelling individuals to engage in more prostitution to replace lost income. |
| Response 28: Establishing Red-Light Districts |
| How It Works: Designated red-light districts aim to concentrate street prostitution in specific, tolerated zones, reducing nuisance complaints in other areas and improving police monitoring. |
| Works Best If: The community is willing to tolerate some level of street prostitution, the red-light district can be adequately policed, and it does not attract additional clients from outside the community. |
| Considerations: Legality is questionable in some jurisdictions (e.g., ruled unconstitutional in Canada as a local option). Red-light districts may lead to the expansion of street prostitution beyond designated zones. Public support is often lacking. Effectiveness in reducing nuisance complaints or harm to sex workers is not guaranteed and can be context-dependent. |
| Response 29: Legalizing and Decriminalizing Prostitution |
| How It Works: Legalization and decriminalization subject prostitution to administrative regulation, aiming to improve worker safety and reduce associated crime by bringing the industry under legal oversight. |
| Works Best If: N/A – Legalization and decriminalization are complex policy choices with broad societal implications. |
| Considerations: Political feasibility is a major hurdle in many regions, including the United States, United Kingdom, and Canada. Raises complex ethical and social debates beyond the scope of immediate street prostitution responses. |
For further information and resources on addressing street prostitution, you can access free bound copies of problem-solving guides through the Department of Justice COPS Response Center:
- Online: Department of Justice COPS Response Center
- Email: [email protected]
- Phone: 800-421-6770 or 202-307-1480
