“Streets of Laredo” stands out as a compelling drama anchored by a stellar cast, even if you’re unfamiliar with the broader “Lonesome Dove” saga. James Garner delivers a powerful performance, reminding audiences why he’s considered an acting icon. Sissy Spacek, as always, is captivating, and the supporting cast is filled with equally talented actors, creating a rich tapestry of characters.
However, viewers acquainted with the “Lonesome Dove” series might find themselves grappling with certain inconsistencies. The timeline feels ambiguous, especially when considering the established history from “Lonesome Dove,” set in 1877. Characters’ ages and relationships appear altered. Woodrow Call, previously depicted as around 50 in “Lonesome Dove,” seems significantly older here. Lorena, once a young, naive woman, is now a mature, worldly schoolteacher married to Pea Eye, who also appears younger and whose backstory doesn’t entirely align with the original narrative. These changes create a sense of disconnect for those deeply invested in the “Lonesome Dove” universe. Questions arise about Woodrow’s presence in Laredo instead of his Montana ranch and the circumstances of Lorena and Pea Eye’s relationship, given Lorena’s journey to San Francisco in the earlier story.
While Larry McMurtry’s novel likely provides context and fills in these narrative gaps, the miniseries perhaps assumes prior knowledge or takes liberties with established details. Despite these potential drawbacks for “Lonesome Dove” enthusiasts, “Streets of Laredo” retains its merit as an independent work.
Ultimately, to fully appreciate “Streets of Laredo,” it’s best to approach it as a standalone drama. Detaching it from the weight of the “Lonesome Dove” legacy allows you to focus on its individual strengths: the exceptional performances and the engaging dramatic storyline. Viewed in this light, “Streets of Laredo” offers a rewarding viewing experience, showcasing fine acting within a well-crafted Western narrative.
