Nestled at the corner of Ninth and Dorman Streets in Indianapolis’ charming Cottage Home neighborhood, the Dorman Street Saloon stands as a testament to time and local history. What began as a humble house in 1871, built for German carpenter Joseph Rieger, has evolved into a beloved neighborhood institution, deeply intertwined with the area’s social fabric. By the dawn of the 20th century, the residence transitioned into a grocery store, eventually adding a front extension that would pave the way for its destiny as a saloon.
Exterior of Dorman Street Saloon, a historic dive bar in Indianapolis' Cottage Home neighborhood on Dorman Street.
Whispers of Dillinger and Prohibition-Era Tales
During the Prohibition era, the Dorman Street establishment operated as a “near beer” provider, ostensibly serving beverages with minimal alcohol content. However, local lore suggests that stronger spirits flowed more freely than officially permitted. Adding to its mystique, persistent rumors link the bar to the infamous John Dillinger, suggesting it was a haunt of the notorious bank robber who targeted a nearby financial institution in 1934. While the bar’s official establishment date is believed to be 1908, continuous operation since then has solidified its place in local memory. Clarence Anacker’s long-term ownership marked a significant period, followed by Jim Taylor who introduced live entertainment, further enhancing the saloon’s appeal.
From “Mahogany Bar” to “The Hog” and Beyond
Over the years, the tavern has donned various monikers. Initially known as the Mahogany Bar, it quickly earned the enduring nickname “The Hog,” a testament to its character that persists even today. In 1982, Mabel Russell took ownership, renaming it May’s Lounge, yet the spirit of “The Hog” remained.
Logo for Dorman Street Saloon in Indianapolis, Indiana. Known locally as "The Hog".
A Blue-Collar Haven with Artistic Touches
Throughout its history, the Dorman Street Saloon has served as a popular hangout, particularly for the working class. It became a regular spot for laborers from nearby roofing and hardwood companies, employees of Schwitzer-Cummins, and residents of the predominantly German and Irish working-class neighborhood. Stepping inside reveals a surprising artistic element: the bar itself originates from the old downtown traction terminal station. Adding to its unique charm, the ceramic tiles adorning the space are the creation of Ernest Batchelder, a celebrated Arts and Crafts ceramist from California.
“Best Dive Bar” and Modern Revival
In 2003, Tammy Miller acquired the saloon, inheriting its sometimes-rowdy reputation. She has successfully maintained its appeal to long-time patrons while also attracting a younger clientele. The Dorman Street Saloon’s enduring character was officially recognized when Indianapolis Monthly named it “Best Dive Bar” for three consecutive years. Adding a new chapter to its story, the saloon is set to reopen its kitchen, offering classic pub fare for lunch and dinner, promising to continue its legacy as a vital part of the Dorman Street and Cottage Home community.
