You can certainly pop into Second Street Bakery in Jersey City for just a loaf of their crusty, coal-fired bread. However, resisting their legendary sandwiches is a true test of willpower. This unassuming takeout spot is renowned for its sandwiches, crafted on Italian loaves baked in the very coal-fired brick oven used by the Siniscalchi family, who established the bakery back in the 1920s.
Don’t be surprised to find a line stretching out the door during lunchtime – it’s a testament to Second Street Bakery’s popularity. If you’re aiming for a quicker visit, breakfast is an excellent time to sample their simple yet satisfying frittata-style egg sandwiches. Options include broccoli rabe, ham, or potatoes, all for a budget-friendly price of $3.50. Beyond breakfast, a tempting array of over two dozen hot and cold sandwich choices awaits.
One must-try is Second Street’s signature sausage bread, generously studded with savory meat chunks. This bread forms the base for a standout sandwich featuring prosciuttini (peppered ham), salami, fresh mozzarella, and roasted peppers, priced at $5.50. For a taste of Sunday dinner in sandwich form, the hot pork brasciole sandwich is a hearty choice ($3.75, or $5 for a half loaf of Italian bread). The lightly breaded eggplant sandwich, a timeless classic, combines fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and a drizzle of balsamic vinegar ($3.95 or $5.50). Other enduring favorites include the meatball parmigiana, hot corned beef, and chicken cutlet sandwiches.
If you’re fortunate enough to visit on a day when the special roast pork sandwich is on offer, it’s highly recommended. This delectable creation features aged provolone, caramelized onions, and a sweet barbecue sauce ($5.50). Second Street Bakery also boasts daily specials encompassing pastas and soups, alongside tempting stuffed rolls, antipasto, and pizza logs – a delightful hybrid of bread and pizza. Planning to feed a crowd? Party platters are readily available to order, making Second Street Bakery a perfect choice for gatherings of any size.
